• Thursday, July 18, 2024
businessday logo


The leadership imperative: Rethinking evaluations and reward systems

Leading with an open heart: The power and peril of vulnerability in the workplace

In the ever-evolving landscape of global business, organisational leaders are standing at a crossroads. The imperative to foster inclusivity within the workplace is not just a moral compass to guide us; it is a strategic imperative that underscores the success of any enterprise. As a writer and leadership expert, I have observed the changing tides of organisational dynamics and the urgent need to revisit our approaches to evaluations and reward systems.

Traditional evaluation methods have long been the bedrock of employee appraisal, determining promotions, bonuses, and career trajectories. However, these systems, often inadvertently, became mirrors reflecting the values of the dominant culture. In a world where the workforce is increasingly diverse, this reflection does not show the whole picture. It is time for leaders to recalibrate their lenses.

Consider the employee who hails from a culture that prizes community success over individual glory. In a system that lauds the lone achiever, this individual’s contributions may be unfairly overshadowed. This is not just a loss for the employee but for the organisation as well. Therein lies the potential of diverse ideas and approaches that remain untapped because our evaluation systems have not evolved to recognize them.

The question then arises: How can organisations adapt their evaluation systems to be truly inclusive? This transformation begins with an acute awareness of cultural contexts. Leaders must first acknowledge the existence of cultural bias within evaluation processes. It is not enough to simply be non-discriminatory; we must be actively anti-bias, especially the unconscious bias.

To this end, training evaluators to recognize and mitigate cultural biases is a vital step. It is a journey that requires introspection and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths. But the fruits of this labour are manifold. An evaluator who understands the multifaceted nature of performance is more likely to identify and nurture talent from all backgrounds.

Furthermore, the criteria upon which we evaluate must be expanded. The traditional metrics of success are often too rigid to capture the diverse strengths of a global workforce. By developing nuanced evaluation criteria, we can begin to value and reward a broader spectrum of achievements. This could mean recognizing the power of collaborative successes, the ability to foster team cohesion, or the capacity to bridge cultural divides within the workplace.

 “Recognition can take many forms, and it must resonate with the values and motivations of a diverse employee base.”

Reward systems, too, must undergo a revolution. Monetary bonuses and promotions are not the sole indicators of achievement. Recognition can take many forms, and it must resonate with the values and motivations of a diverse employee base. This may mean offering flexible working arrangements, opportunities for professional growth, or creating platforms for employees to showcase their cultural heritage and insights.

Inclusivity is not a box to be checked. It is a continuous process that enriches the organisational fabric. When we recognize the collective achievements alongside the individual ones, we send a powerful message: every contribution is valued, and every effort is seen. This is a catalyst for innovation and engagement.

It is also worth noting that inclusivity is not just about cultural diversity. It extends to gender, age, disability, and all the manifold ways in which humans are diverse. A truly inclusive evaluation system will recognize and reward the single parent who balances work and family commitments with grace, the older employee who brings years of invaluable experience, and the differently-abled employee whose unique perspective drives innovation.

The benefits of rethinking evaluations and reward systems are not just felt at the individual level. They ripple outwards, enhancing the organisation’s reputation as an employer of choice. In a world where talent is the ultimate currency, being known for an inclusive culture is a competitive advantage.

Moreover, inclusivity in evaluations and rewards fosters a sense of belonging among employees. When people feel valued for who they are, their commitment to the organisation deepens. They are more likely to stay longer, reducing turnover and the associated costs of recruitment and training.

But perhaps the most compelling reason to rethink our evaluation and reward systems is the simple, unassailable fact that it is the right thing to do. In a world fraught with divisions, the workplace can be a microcosm of what society can aspire to be, a workplace that values every individual, that harnesses the strength in our differences, and celebrates the collective over the singular.

Therefore, organisational leaders must be the vanguards of change. It is incumbent upon them to champion the cause of inclusivity, not just in words but in the very systems that underpin their operations. Rethinking evaluations and reward systems is not just a step towards inclusivity; it is a stride towards organisational excellence. Let us then embrace this challenge with the knowledge that in the tapestry of human endeavour, every thread counts, and it is the diversity of these threads that makes the fabric strong, resilient, and beautiful.

Conversely, the journey toward this inclusive excellence is not without its challenges. It requires a paradigm shift in how we conceive of work, success, and merit. It is about moving beyond the comfort zone of the traditional evaluation and reward paradigm, which has been deeply ingrained in corporate culture. But as daunting as this task may seem, it is not insurmountable. It begins with small, intentional steps that collectively transform the organisational ethos.

Thus, the future of work is calling for leaders who are not only strategic thinkers but also empathetic listeners, who are not only goal-oriented but also values-driven. These leaders will understand that the true measure of an organisation’s success is not solely in its profits but also in the well-being and development of its people.


About the Author

Dr. Toye Sobande is a strategic leadership expert, lawyer, public speaker, and trainer. He is the CEO of Stephens Leadership Consultancy LLC, a strategy and management consulting firm offering creative insight and solutions to businesses and leaders. Email: [email protected]