• Friday, March 29, 2024
businessday logo

BusinessDay

Foreign investors say Nigeria’s FX policy overshadowing power, fuel reforms

Debt, poor policies impeding Nigeria’s petroleum sector

Nigeria’s renewed push to reform its power and petroleum sectors by doing away with subsidies and enthroning a market-based pricing system is being undermined by the country’s foreign exchange policy which is keeping foreign investors on the sidelines.

“Efforts to remove the fuel and power subsidies are positives but there are negatives like the foreign exchange policy and closed land borders which limit how positive you can be in investing in Nigeria,” said Erik Renander, a London-based portfolio manager of a multi-asset fund which invests in fixed income and equities across Africa.

Renander, who spoke at Business Day’s capital market and investing conference Thursday, said, “The fx policy is hurting investment appetite (in naira assets) and Nigeria is on hold for now in terms of new foreign investment.”
“If you want to invest in Nigeria where there is a risk of not knowing when you are able to get out, the 2 percent yield on T-bills is not enough,” said Renander, who sold his holdings in Nigerian Treasury Bills in February after he became “nervous” about oil prices and the CBN’s fx policy.
Another foreign investor told BusinessDay that “ordinarily, the stock market, for instance, should be doing much better now following the government’s renewed push for reforms that have cast a dark cloud on Nigeria for years but it’s not happening because of the fx situation”.

“The power and fuel subsidy removals are potential game changers if the government follows through, but the economy may not reap the full dividends with such a foreign exchange policy,” the South Africa-based fund manager told BusinessDay.

Oscar Onyema, chief executive officer of the Nigerian Stock Exchange, said the exchange was in talks with the CBN to find a way to address the foreign exchange situation which has cast a lull on the market. The market is down some 5 percent year to date as foreigners who have historically led activity in the market snub equities.

Several investors have criticised Nigeria’s foreign exchange management which has led to a rising dollar demand backlog which the CBN puts at $2 billion.

With some investors’ funds trapped in the country, Nigeria has fallen out of favour with foreigners.

For the first time in more than four years, no single foreigner invested in Nigerian bonds, according to data by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS).

That compares with the $231 million and $361.2 million invested in Nigerian bonds in the preceding quarter and the same period last year.

But it’s not only foreign investors who are reeling from Nigeria’s dollar crunch. Local manufacturers, who are unable to get enough dollars to import key inputs and banks, who are limiting dollar transactions on naira cards, are also feeling the pinch.

Nigeria, Africa’s biggest economy, is grappling with a dollar crisis caused by the double whammy of the coronavirus pandemic and a deep plunge in crude oil prices, the country’s biggest foreign exchange earner.

“The apathy seen by foreign investors is a combination of the effect of low yields that we have in the bond market due to the Open Market Operations (OMO) policy last year and also a risk aversion for Nigerian securities due to a lack of FX liquidity,” said Omotola Abimbola, a fixed income and macroeconomist at Lagos-based Chapel Hill Denham.

“As investors are thinking of coming in, they also have to think of the ease in going out. It is only normal that if you have your money trapped inside to the extent you can’t take it out, you won’t bring in any fresh capital until you are sure that there is clarity in getting your money out,” he said.