2019 was a phenomenal year for Ghana, Tanzania and Uganda regarding DFS growth. Ghana captured the headlines several times with impressive mobile money adoption and transaction numbers. However, the narrative concerning Nigeria is yet to turn for the better even as our financial inclusion progress has been minimal over the past few years.
Since the NFIS refresh in 2018, several stakeholders have been questioning Nigeria’s ability to meet the 2020 deadline and for good reason. The 2018 EFinA Access to Finance survey revealed that 36.6 million Nigerians live without access to financial services. Even mobile money, which was heralded to be the “magic bullet” to Nigeria’s financial inclusion woes, has failed to gain the anticipated traction as in other countries.
Despite the various regulatory and market interventions since 2009, Nigeria’s financial services industry is still plagued by non-consumption.
Popularized by Harvard Business School Professor, Clayton Christensen, non-consumption is the inability of an entity (person or organization) to purchase and use a product or service required to fulfill an important job. This inability to purchase arise from a series of constraints such as market affordability (cost), institutional voids or complexities (enabling environment) or resource or scarcity (convenience) and the like.
Christensen argues that in emerging markets, non-consumption is a common phenomenon that plagues various industries meant to improve human life and wellbeing. The list of sectors and industries plagued by non-consumption is extensive including health services, mobility, entertainment, housing, energy etc.
In highlighting the gap, Christensen’s proposes the solution – market-creating interventions.
Market-creating innovations address non-consumption by transforming complex and expensive products into simpler and affordable versions, increasing their availability to the larger society. In financial services, this is the conversion of complex financial products and services into affordable and simpler versions accessible to the excluded community. Examples include m-Pesa, Paga, Microensure and Zoona.
In Nigeria, our financial inclusion journey which commenced in 2009 is still wavering and we believe a different approach is required. On November 28, 2019, the Sustainable and Inclusive Digital Financial Services (SIDFS) initiative of the Lagos Business School will host the 2019 International Financial Inclusion Conference. The conference focuses on non-consumption, highlighting the need for significant and holistic paradigm shifts in several areas including:
- Business models and capabilities that target non-consumption. In Nigeria’s financial services ecosystem, innovations and business models still appear to be designed for the banked customer. The non-consuming population (i.e. the financially excluded) comprises of women, smallholder farmers and micro and small enterprises. Can financial institutions design products and services that meet the needs of these customer segments and will they be viable?
- New value networks. Brick and mortar branches are the conventional distribution model for financial services. The disadvantages of this model have become apparent even as digital technology continues to disrupt the industry with new distribution models and cost structures that facilitate affordable service provision to non-consumers. But what will it take for current service providers to explore new models and cost structures? What are the implications?
- An emergent strategy. Because non-consumption markets are undefined, providers need emergent, not deliberate, strategies that address market needs. However, providers require wisdom to acquire the relevant market insights as well as how to reformulate their strategies. How can this process be accelerated?
- Executive support. Like other businesses that target non-consumption, financial inclusion initiatives with their apparently unsustainable lower margins, high capital requirements and undefined markets (in the context of businesses not configured for bottom of the pyramid markets) are unlikely to win executive management support. What should be done to ensure better success for pitching innovative products that target non-consumption?
The issues highlighted in this article are just the tip of the iceberg. Nevertheless, they must be addressed to unlock financial services at the bottom of the pyramid, and ultimately move the financial inclusion needle. Developing market-creating interventions are a strategic imperative for targeting bottom of the pyramid markets across industries. Our conversations at the IFI Conference will provoke the status quo and hopefully trigger appropriate actions.
Professor Olayinka David-West and Ibukun Taiwo
Professor Olayinka David-West and Ibukun Taiwo are members of the Sustainable and Inclusive Digital Financial Services initiative at the Lagos Business School