In the last couple of years, notably since the global economic downturn in 2008, patronage of the grey import market has grown due to its relatively affordable options. The grey market goods are relatively affordable due to the sharp practices of the grey market dealers who act with near impunity. Practices such as an under-declaration of goods and other methods to pay lower import duty have created distortions in the market.
The Nigerian automobile market is mainly divided into two categories: “New” and “Used”. Used cars form a sizeable portion of total imports. The new car segment’s profit margin is being eroded by the increasing grey import and patronage as the majority of Nigerians have limited means to buy new vehicles from authorised sources.
The automobile industry in Nigeria dates back to the early 1960s when private companies pioneered the establishment of local automobile assembly plants using completely/semi knocked-down parts. The Federal Government became involved in the local automobile production 10 years later after concluding agreements with automobile manufacturers in Europe. Installed capacity of the Nigerian automobile plants was to produce 108,000 cars, 56,000 commercial vehicles, 10,000 tractors, 1,000,000 motorcycles and 1,000,000 bicycles annually. Given that the industry works at full capacity, it could provide over 300,000 different jobs. However, as the country grew into an oil-dependent economy in the late 1970s, and the government policy on importation became flexible, automobile manufacturing became difficult and local manufacturing plants could not bear the growing high cost of production. As a result, capacity utilisation in the automobile industry over the years dropped below expectation with vehicle manufacturing below 10 percent. In order to revive the automobile industry, the government introduced several importation policies and established the National Automotive Council (NAC) to ensure the survival and growth of the Nigerian automobile industry using local human and material resources. The overall goal was to enhance the industry’s contribution to the national economy. Vehicle importation, however, continued to thrive due to the infinite duty evasion techniques by the grey market dealers and sloppy importation policy enforcement, despite the government’s efforts to boost local production.
Sufficient local production turned import-driven
The failed state of the local industry gave way to growing importation of global brands. The industry is almost entirely import-driven occasioned by the non-existence of local brands and the desire for personally-owned vehicles due to the poor state of public transportation in the country. Massive importation of vehicles led to sole distributorship arrangements with major global car makers and their Nigerian partners. The sole partnership was a good development as it provided employment (though not comparable to local manufacturing) and increased government revenue through customs duty and excise collection. In addition, indirect taxes are collected from the locally registered partners. The Nigerian automobile industry also comprises unauthorised car dealers who import vehicles from choice locations according to the customers’ demand. The unauthorised dealers are referred to as grey dealers and their smuggling/duty evasion activities in the Nigerian market have a negative effect on the authorised dealers and also limited government revenue collected through indirect taxes and customs/excise duty. The volume of vehicles annually imported into Nigeria is about 50,000 new vehicles and 200,000 used ones imported via official channels.
Grey imports can be put into three categories: “unintended”, “licensed” and “distress” goods. Unintended vehicles are vehicles that are authorised for sale in one country but get redirected to another and directly compete with the authorised distributors when they get to that country. Licensed vehicles are products manufactured in agreement with a trademark licence but sold through unauthorised channels. Distress vehicles are the vehicles dumped by a dealer or company who is authorised in the circumstances, because they have excess supply or the goods are outdated.
Imported vehicles by grey importers in Nigeria fall in all three categories as they are manufactured and intended mostly for other countries. However, due to trademark agreements with other companies and excess production by the manufacturers, some of the vehicles are imported to and sold in Nigeria by the grey dealers. Grey imports compete on the basis of price. They are usually cheaper than the officially-imported vehicles of the same model that are imported legally and sometimes have more enhanced features compared to those from authorised dealers. The used vehicles market also provides consumers with a variety of choices for their taste and budget. Increased vehicle import by grey dealers is estimated at an annual rate of 15 percent-20 percent. In addition, customs duty and excise avoidance contributed to the increasing loss to government revenue through these sources while indirect taxes are usually not paid by the grey dealers due to their business structure.
The potential for growth of the Nigerian automobile industry remains strong. In a country of over 160m people, there are approximately 8m vehicles bringing the ratio to 16 passenger vehicles for every 1,000 persons. This does not compare favourably with South Africa which has a ratio of 159 passenger vehicles for every 1,000 persons. This gap creates a unique opportunity for players in the industry.
A report by analysts at Financial Derivatives