This year, one of the major talking points for most Nigerians is a controversy between wealthier Nigerian states and the federal government over who should collect Value Added Tax (VAT), a tax levied on the price of a product or service at each stage of production, distribution or sale.
Customarily, the federal government through the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) collects VAT in each of the 36 states of the federation, remitting certain percentages to state and local governments every month. The distribution formula includes 15 percent to the federal government, 50 percent to state governments, and 35 percent to local governments.
However, in 2021, some states argued that the federal collection of VAT is defined by structural inadequacies and unfair distribution among the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory (FCT). Wealthier states are leading a revolt against the current state of affairs, arguing that they should keep more of the cash raised in their own states.
Last September, a Court of Appeal in Abuja granted an injunction pending an appeal for states to maintain the status quo, meaning that both Lagos and Rivers states are likely to desist from actually collecting VAT until a definitive judgment is made by the Supreme Court, which is likely to ultimately decide the issue.
Despite the controversy, BusinessDay’s analysis showed how some states, sectors, and industries performed in 2021.
Top 10 States in VAT Remittance
From January to August 2021, Lagos; Rivers; and Oyo State topped the list of the most states generating VAT with the total amount of N429.20 billion, N90.293 billion and N64.646 billion respectively which represented 55.3 percent, 11.6 percent, and 8.3 percent generated by States during the period respectively.
On the other hand, Zamfara, Benue, and Kebbi State generated the lowest revenue of N598.1 million, N1.268 billion, and N1.284 billion during the same period under review.
Top 10 States in VAT allocation
Lagos, Kano, and Rivers State got the highest VAT state allocation from January to August 2021, with totals of N139.59 billion, N47.08 billion, and N46.27 billion, representing 13.6 percent, 4.6 percent, and 4.5 percent of VAT generated by states during the time, respectively.
On the contrary, Nasarawa, Gombe, and Bayelsa state received less of the VAT revenue of N16.872 billion, N17.650 billion, and N17.659 billion.
Total VAT in 2021
The total value-added tax (VAT) collected in the first, second, and third quarters of 2021 was N496.39 billion, N512.25 billion, and N500.49 billion, respectively, compared to N324.58 billion, N327.20 billion, and N424.71 billion in the same quarter previous year.
This denotes higher revenue in the first three quarters of 2021, indicating an increase in collections. This spike indicates growth rates of 52.93 percent in Q1 2021, 56.56 percent in Q2 2021, and 17.84 percent in Q3 2021 when compared on a year-on-year basis.
Top 5 VAT Sectorial Collection in 2021
Q1’2021
Looking at the sectoral collection of revenue generated over the period, collections from the Non-Import (foreign) VAT; Nigeria customs service-import (NCS-import) VAT and Other Manufacturing accounted for the top three largest generations of revenue in Q1 2021 with N171.66 billion, N99.88 billion, and N49.41 billion which represented 34.58 percent, 20.12 percent and 9.95 percent of the total VAT collected respectively.
Q2’2021
Similarly, the Non-Import (foreign) VAT; NCS-Import VAT; and Other Manufacturing accounted for the top three largest generations of revenue in Q2 2021 with N207.69billion, N117.13billion, and N44.89billion which denoted 40.54percent, 22.8percent, and 8.76percent of the total VAT collected respectively.
Read also: FG sees revenue to GDP rising to 15%
Q3’2021
For the Q3’2021 record, the NCS-Import VAT; Manufacturing; Non-Import (foreign) VAT accounted for the top three largest generations of revenue in Q3 2021 with N123.76 billion, N91.20 billion, and N81.26 billion representing 24.73 percent, 18.22 percent, and 16.24 percent of the total VAT collected respectively.
